New Data: Nearly 1 in 300 Samples Of Ground Beef Contain E. Coli

New York, NY – In response to a new report out this month from United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) showing nearly 1 out of every 300 samples of ground beef contains E. coli, U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, the first New York senator to sit on the Senate Agriculture Committee in nearly 40 years, joined today with consumers who have contracted E. coli from contaminated food, plus medical and food safety experts to announce the E. coli Eradication Act. This new legislation authored by Gillibrand would for the first time mandate E. coli inspections of all ground beef. While there is currently no federal requirement for meat grinders to test their products for the virus, the number of annual recalls nationally of ground beef and other beef products contaminated with E. coli is in the double digits and 58 New York City residents were afflicted with E. coli last year alone.

To further highlight the need to significantly overhaul the nation’s food safety laws for the first time in more than a century, Gillibrand released new data showing that over 900 food products have been recalled from New York City shelves for various violations since 2005. The list of recalled products include turkey breast, glazed ham, fresh vegetables, chocolate cheese spread, caramel spread, preserved olives, dried prunes and chicken frankfurters. The Senator outlined a comprehensive food safety plan to improve inspection, recall response, and public education. 

“In America, in 2009, it is unconscionable that food is still going straight to our kitchens, school cafeterias and restaurants without being properly tested to ensure its safety,” Senator Gillibrand said. “It’s spreading too many diseases and costing too many lives. We need to do a better job of catching contaminated food before it ever comes close to a kitchen table. My plan addresses the gaps in the inspection process and improves recalls and public education, so parents have the information to keep their families safe.”

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), every year an estimated 87 million Americans are sickened by contaminated food, 371,000 are hospitalized with food-borne illness, and 5,700 die from food-related disease. In New York City, approximately 2.1 million people are afflicted with a food-borne illness each year.

Salmonella is the most common food-borne illness – causing over 1 million illnesses each year in the U.S., according to the CDC. Another 70,000 in America fall victim to E. coli each year. From meat and poultry to peanut butter, fruits and vegetables, almost every type of food we eat each day has the potential for contamination because of outdated, insufficient safeguards and testing processes.

Senator Gillibrand’s office compiled new data which shows that over 900 food products have been recalled for various violations since 2005.

 

Number of Recalled Food Products in New York City Per Year
	2009	2008	2007	2006	2005	Total Years
Bronx	5	8	33	31	7	84
Brooklyn	40	137	86	151	126	540
Manhattan	18	31	10	23	22	104
Queens	31	30	60	59	31	211
Total	94	206	189	264	186	939

 

Some of these recalled products include:

 

Product	Reason	Borough
Mexican Fruit Candy	Lead	Bronx
Chicken Frankfurters	Listera	Brooklyn
Golden Taste Tuna Deluxe	Listeria	Brooklyn
Caramel Spread	Lead	Brooklyn
Chocolate Cheese Spread	Contaminated	Brooklyn
Fresh Vegetables	Listeria	Manhattan
Boars Head Ham Maple Glazed	Listeria	Queens
Turkey Breast	Listeria	Queens
Peanut Punch	Bacteria	Queens
Preserved Olive	Banned Additive	Queens
Dried Prune	Banned Additive	Queens

 

Responsibility for enforcing America’s food safety measures is shared by 15 federal agencies – with the FDA and USDA responsible for the bulk of the oversight.  However, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is often limited to reactive regulations once outbreaks have already begun instead of preventing contaminations from spreading, and risking the safety of our food and the health of millions.

Senator Gillibrand’s plan to improve food safety will streamline and strengthen regulations at the USDA and FDA.  Senator Gillibrand’s efforts will also alter the fundamental approach to food safety by focusing on prevention to catch food-borne illnesses, and more quickly preventing further illness when an outbreak is detected.

The Gillibrand Food Safety Plan:

1. Strengthen Inspection and Surveillance

Improve Testing of Ground Beef
During a 2008 industry-wide sampling of all ground beef produced, the USDA found that 0.32% of ground beef was contaminated with E. coli – nearly 1 in every 300 samples.  Ground beef is especially vulnerable to E.coli because its source material is not from a single cut of meat, rather, it is a compilation of trimmings from many parts, including fat that lies near the surface of possibly contaminated hide. While some grinders that process ground beef voluntarily test the meat before and after grinding, there is currently no federal requirement for grinders to test their ingredients for E. coli. 

To reduce the risk of E. coli ending up in the hamburgers and other food we eat, Senator Gillibrand is authoring the E. Coli Eradication Act – new legislation that would require all plants that process ground beef to test their products regularly when it is ground and again before it is combined with other beef or ingredients, such as spices, and packaged. If ground beef is found to be contaminated, the bill requires the company to properly dispose of the contaminated batch, or cook the meat to a temperature that destroys the e.coli.

Improve Regulation of All Other Food
Ground beef isn’t the only food infecting people with E. coli and salmonella. Fruits and vegetables can also be contaminated. Senator Gillibrand is co-sponsoring the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act – legislation authored by Senator Dick Durbin that would make comprehensive improvements to the safety of fruits and vegetables, and help prevent outbreaks before they start.

• Focus on Prevention, requiring all facilities to establish preventive plans to address hazards upfront, prevent adulteration, and give the FDA access to all of these plans and procedures.
• Expand Access to Records, giving the FDA access to the records of all food processing facilities.
• Establish Oversight of High Quality Testing Laboratories, by granting the FDA authority to check the credibility of the laboratories testing the safety of food, requiring the labs to report all of their findings to the FDA, and certify that foreign food facilities comply with U.S. food safety standards.
• Improve Detection, by increasing inspections at all food facilities, including annual inspections of high-risk facilities, and inspections of all facilities once every four years; enhancing food-borne illness surveillance systems to improve the collection, analysis, reporting, and usefulness of data on food-borne illnesses; and creating a pilot project to test and evaluate new methods to quickly and accurately track and trace fruits and vegetables in the event of a food-borne illness outbreak.
• Enhance U.S. Food Defense Capabilities by helping food companies protect their products from intentional contamination, and commence a national strategy to protect our food supply from terrorist threats, and rapidly respond to food emergencies.
• Increase FDA Resources, increasing federal investments to give the FDA all the resources it needs to implement comprehensive food safety improvements.

Improve Safety of Imported Food 15 percent of America’s overall food supply is imported from overseas, including 60 percent of fruits and vegetables and 80 percent of seafood.

America imports $5.2 billion worth of food from China alone – including 10 percent of our shrimp. In 2007, the FDA issued important alerts for five kinds of farm-raised fish and shrimp from China due to unsafe additives, inadequate labeling and poor manufacturer registrations, as well as potentially harmful veterinary drug residues in farm-raised fish and shrimp.

To ensure the safety of food we import matches the standards of food grown and processed in America, Senator Gillibrand is calling on the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to prioritize the hiring of inspectors to protect consumers from contaminated imported food.

In 2003, when the DHS took over the inspection of agricultural products on the border, the position of “agriculture specialists” was created.  While the number of people in this position has been slowly increasing, we are still one-third short of the number of specialists needed to test the ever increasing array of agricultural products coming into the country.

The overall agricultural inspection rate for cargo has declined from nearly 70 percent in 2001 to about 40 percent in 2008 and down to 13 percent for passenger inspections.  Better inspections will not only protect humans from pathogens, but will protect American farms from agricultural pests and disease.

Additionally, Senator Gillibrand will work to require importers to verify the safety of foreign suppliers and imported food by allowing the FDA to require certification for high-risk foods, and deny entry to a food that lacks certification, or that is from a foreign facility that has refused U.S. inspections.

2. Improve Recall Response

Recall Contaminated Food in School Lunches
Last month, in response to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report that revealed federal agencies are not adequately alerting schools about recalls, Senator Gillibrand introduced the Safe Food for Schools Act – legislation that would protect the 31 million schoolchildren who participate in the National School Lunch and School Breakfast programs by requiring federal agencies to issue proper alerts to schools.

Make Recalls of Contaminated Food Mandatory For additional improvements to our food recall processes, Senator Gillibrand will work with her colleagues to give the FDA the authority to order a mandatory recall of a food product when a company fails to voluntarily recall the produce upon FDA’s request.  Right now, recalls are only voluntary.

3. Improve Public Education

To make sure information about food-borne illnesses and recalls is distributed accurately and efficiently, Senator Gillibrand is authoring the Consumer Recall Notification Act ­– legislation that would direct the Secretaries of the Department of Health and Human Services and the USDA, as well as the Commissioner of the FDA to improve communication among states, state and local health departments, food distributors and vendors to provide consumers with faster and more complete information.

Specifically, the legislation would:

• Provide information to health professionals to improve diagnosis and treatment of food-related illness;
• Develop a procedure to distribute regional and national advisories concerning food safety;
• Allow the FDA to share trade secrets, and commercial or financial information, and its list of registered facilities with other federal, state, local and foreign agencies – provided those agencies can assure confidentially of the information;
• Allow the FDA to share confidential information with the public when necessary to protect public health;
• Develop standardized formats for written and broadcast advisories;

Mandate on-site notification of a recalled product by posting notification in the freezer case or shelving unit where the product is, or has been sold.